Human rights defenders explain why reviving military courts in Ukraine will not solve army problems
The debate over the return of military justice continues, but the «Pryncyp» human rights center warns against creating separate military courts due to the risks of command influence on the judiciary.
🛡️SecurityPhoto: Ukrainska Pravda
Key points
- The debate on military courts continues in the Verkhovna Rada.
- Pryncyp human rights defenders warn against command influence on judges.
- Specialization of civilian judges is proposed instead of creating new institutions.
The debate surrounding military justice
The issue of restoring the system of military courts and prosecutors has once again moved to the forefront of public attention in Ukraine. Following the liquidation of such institutions in 2010 and against the backdrop of full-scale aggression, lawmakers have established a Temporary Special Commission to review this matter, involving human rights organizations. The main argument of proponents of these changes is that military cases should be considered by individuals with actual service experience, as civilian judges allegedly cannot fully grasp the realities of military life.
However, specialists from the «Pryncyp» human rights center for military personnel urge caution regarding potential threats. The modern Ukrainian judicial system is built on the principles of independence and impartiality, whereas military service relies on a single-command structure and strict subordination. Blending these two distinct spheres by granting military ranks to judges could pave the way for direct or indirect influence from the Ministry of Defense or the General Staff over judicial decisions.
Why civilian judges can handle the tasks
Human rights defenders emphasize that holding military status does not automatically guarantee a deep understanding of laws and regulations. Furthermore, combat experience does not ensure absolute objectivity, as a judge might either become harsher on defendants or overly lenient toward specific infractions. When specialized knowledge is required, civilian courts already possess effective tools, such as engaging certified experts and specialists during legal proceedings.
«For a service member whose case is being reviewed, all of this creates a risk that the decision will be influenced by the command vertical rather than solely by the law and the facts of the case», — note the experts from «Pryncyp».
Instead of undertaking the risky process of building a separate network of military courts, experts suggest focusing on developing specialization among existing civilian judges. In their view, deepening judges' expertise in crimes against the established order of military service will improve the quality of justice without threatening the independence of the judiciary or the rights of service members.
Source Ukrainska Pravda — pravda.com.ua/news/2026/11/20/8063800/ ↗
Read next
🎭Culture & SportAC Milan secure dominant win over Frosinone to reach Serie A top four
AC Milan defeated Frosinone 5-1 in the 12th round of Serie A, moving up to fourth place in the league standings.
🏛️PoliticsEnergy system of Ukraine: power outage schedules for November 23
Due to the consequences of enemy attacks on energy infrastructure, planned power outages are being implemented across Ukraine on November 23.
Power System Under Strain: Strict Blackout Schedules Set for Monday
On Monday, November 23, hourly power outage schedules will be implemented across several regions of Ukraine following recent attacks on energy infrastructure.
Bundeswehr intends to test and integrate Ukrainian combat management system Delta
The German Armed Forces plan to test the Ukrainian-developed Delta system for potential integration into their military structures.
AfD Co-leader announces plans for mass deportation of foreigners
AfD leader Tino Chrupalla has called for the deportation of 2.6 million foreigners, including Ukrainians, if security conditions in their home countries improve.
🎭Culture & SportAirstrike on Sloviansk: Casualties Reported Following Guided Bomb Attack
Two people were killed and three others injured after a Russian guided bomb struck an apartment building in Sloviansk.